release date: Mar. 17, 2015
format: cd
[album rate: 3,5 / 5] [3,62]
producer: Isaac Brock, Tucker Martine, Brian Deck, Andrew Weiss, Clay Jones
label: Epic Records - nationality: USA
Track highlights: 1. "Strangers to Ourselves" - 2. "Lampshades on Fire" (live) - 3. "Shit in Your Cut" - 5. "Ansel" - 6. "The Ground Walks, With Time in a Box" - 7. "Coyotes" - 8. "Pups to Dust" - 12. "God Is an Indian and You're an Asshole" - 14. "The Best Room"
6th studio album by Modest Mouse is the band's first full studio album in 8 years, and the line-up has changed considerably over this relatively long time span. Former The Smiths guitarist Johnny Marr, who only took part in the band line-up from 2006-09, left the band (and joined The Cribs in 2009) and he was replaced by Jim Fairchild. 2012 meant even bigger changes as founding member and bassist Eric Judy and percussionist Joe Plummer both left the band - their replacements were Russell Higbee and Davey Brozowski, and the band was expanded by multi-instrumentalist and vocalist Lisa Molinaro - and in 2014 also percussionist Ben Massarella, who had previously contributed on The Moon & Antarctica joined the group. This means that by now only the band's leader, vocalist and lyricist Isaac Brock and drummer Jeremiah Green have been in the band since 1993, and that Modest Mouse, which started out as a trio by now has become an octet.
The long time span and a completely new line-up sounds like something that would leave more than a significant mark on the output, but Strangers to Ourselves ultimately sounds like Modest Mouse more than anything and almost strangely follows closely on the path laid out on the 2007 album. Brock and Green sharing the steering wheel apparently guarantee the destination of the ride, where the journey perhaps has become more laid back and gentle. A song like "Lampshades on Fire", "Ansel" and "The Ground Walks, With Time in a Box" are songs that could easily have been part of the 2007 release, whereas other compositions are less energetic and seem more driven by narration. Without being weak, the opening title track really takes off in a completely new territory, which could scare some fans off, but the whole album is more than anything a solid experiment and pleasant return of this fascinating band. From my perspective, the album is a typical Modest Mouse album as it contains chorus-founded and melody-driven uptempo tracks and a particular amount of quirkiness. It also has the qualities of stronger albums as it unfolds itself along the way. It seems that no matter what happens in and around this band, Isaac Brock remains the captain of this vessel called Modest Mouse, and he makes sure that no matter the obstacles ahead, he'll bring forth the goods.
[ allmusic.com, The Guardian, Q Magazine 3 / 5, Rolling Stone, NME 3,5 / 5, Uncut 4 / 5 stars ]
