release date: Jun. 10, 2011
format: digital
[album rate: 2,5 / 5] [2,46]
producer: Neil Young & Ben Keith
label: Reprise Records - nationality: Canada
Track highlights: 11. "Nothing Is Perfect" - 12. "Grey Riders"
A live album by Neil Young released as Neil Young International Harvesters features live recordings from his 1984-1985 U.S. tour with the International Harvesters, and it's volume nine in Young's "Archives Performance Series" and the sixth to be released. The material is a blend of old familiar songs, newer ones and previously unreleased material all played in the style of country rock.
One could suspect Young from having landed in a track where he's 'obligated' to release a new album every year now time is ticking away. Sure, it's not going faster, but Neil may have come across the thought that he he doesn't have his life in front of him anymore. So when he doesn't feel like releasing brand new material, he can always turn to his "Archives".
I think, it's great that he wants to share all that filed material of his, but it does make it strange to sit down and be forced to think some 30 years back and think: "how good was it then?" vs. "how good is it today?" And regardless the answer be able to acknowledge these recordings from a contemporary point of view considering time, quality and legitimacy.
In the early and mid 1980s Young seemed lost. He bounced from one style to another trying to be modern or contemporary enough to keep up and still be popular or worthwhile. And he failed time after time releasing the albums Hawks & Doves, Re-ac-tor, Trans, Everybody's Rockin', Old Ways and Landing on Water - all unsuccessfully. Is this his way of returning to his dark(est) ages by pointing out that he stood firm and still played great songs? We can't really tell. But listening to the songs here I find it difficult to greet these country rock songs as "A Treasure" to pay tribute to. We've really heard this dozen times or more (or more), and no matter when, I don't really like Young's country rock. Period. Yes, when he played After the Gold Rush and Harvest it made sense, but not in the mid 80s or today. It doesn't contain memorable stuff and it's not good.
Not recommendable.
[ allmusic.com, Rolling Stone 4 / 5 stars ]
