release date: Nov. 12, 2002
format: digital
[album rate: 3,5 / 5]
producer: diverse
label: Polydor / Wonderland - nationality: England, UK
2 CD best of album by Siouxsie and the Banshees released six years after the disbandment is basically the first release with the attempt to collect the band's best tracks.
It's quite obvious a pure record company's idea without intentions of trying to document what the band has really contributed with in a music historical perspective. And the selection of 'the best' compositions hasn't included advice, wishes, guidance from the band members. When you take a closer look at what may have been the trigger for Polydor / Universal 'suddenly' manufacturing an idea to release this album at this very instant, it's striking that former band members Sioux, Severin, and Budgie together with guitarist Knox Chandler met in April 2002 to discuss the preparation of a reunion tour, which they called the "Seven Year Itch tour", which took place in the Summer of 2002, and handpicked tracks from this tour ended up on the live album Seven Year Itch - Live (2003). And yes, the (former) record company then found a way to perhaps ride on the new interest for the band and to earn a little extra profit from that...
The Best of... consists of two CDs, where CD 1, with its 15 tracks mainly originate from the band's later years, and it has a total running length of approx. 57 minutes. CD 2, with 9 tracks, all of which are various extended editions or peculiar mixes, has a total running length of just under 65 minutes.
Let me cut to the conclusion: this is by no means the best of a band who has successfully changed style from album to album over almost two decades, starting out as a post-punk band with strong ties to punk, then becoming one of the most significant style-creating bands of the establishment of both gothic rock and later darkwave styles. Later on, they have progressed again as a distinct kind of pop and alt. dance group, and it's pretty much only this last chapter you'll find being exposed on this very release. The selected tracks are fine - as it's difficult to list fifteen tracks with a band, who have made so many fine songs, without it being automatically a successful selection, however, at the same time it is a somewhat strange experience listening through an album that starts with the band's commercial breakthrough - the cover "Dear Prudence", which, despite its qualities, in no way rightfully represents the band's original contribution to music history. Admittedly, a few well-known tracks from their early period have been included, but the jump from alt. dance tracks back to dark electric gothic rock, and then ending as it started with their most recent period, seems like the strangest journey.
Two fine compilations were released during the band's lifetime: Once Upon a Time / The Singles from '81, which nicely documents the band's earliest music, and then Twice Upon a Time - The Singles from '92, which admittedly doesn't include tracks from the band's final album - but together these are a much better choice than The Best Of.
Not recommended.
[ allmusic.com 3 / 5 stars ]
