release date: Nov. 1983
format: cd (1998 reissue)
[album rate: 3,5 / 5] [3,66]
producer: Martin Hayles
label: Polydor - nationality: Scotland, UK
Track highlights: 1. "Rip It Up" (4 / 5) (live) - 2. "A Million Pleading Faces" - 3. "Mud in Your Eye" - 4. "Turn Away" - 6. "I Can't Help Myself" (live) - 7. "Flesh of My Flesh"
*The 1998 remaster contains 3 bonus tracks
2nd studio album by Orange Juice released only nine months after the debut from Feb. '83 doesn't sound much like the former, and basically more than anything reflects the band's transformation rather than its natural progression. Fact is, both drummer Steven Daly and guitarist James Kirk left the band soon after having released You Can't Hide Your Love Forever. Replacing members are guitarist Malcolm Ross (ex-Joseph K) and drummer Zeke Manyika. Having substituted half of the band the end result is noticeable. The music is still indie pop, but what was left of post punk influence seems abandoned here. There's also less focus on the bold jangle pop element that had put the band alongside its Glasgow comrades in Aztec Camera. Instead, this new formation has put emphasis on funk and African music influences, and I can't help thinking that they play closer to the many sources of inspiration one will hear in music by Talking Heads - also with a distinct new wave touch that wasn't found on the predecessor.
I don't recall hearing the album back in '83, although, I'm quite certain I came across the title track, which I thought had a great guitar hook in the chorus, but after my first listens back when the album was re-issued (the remastered edition of '98), I must say that I find it a clearly lesser album compared to the strong debut. Edwyn Collins still sings in his highly original way, which then almost is the only common ground one will find on the two albums.
The album peaked as number #39 on the UK albums chart list, but the single release of the title track reached number #8 on the singles list making it the band's only true hit. Subsequently, also track #7 was issued as a single but only reached a position as number #41. The album is enlisted in "1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die".
Rip It Up undoubtedly sounds more polished but it also points in many directions and despite the extraordinary songwriting craftmanship of Collins it's an album left without that something that could've held it all together. It's not that the songs are poor compositions, 'cause several great tracks appear here, neither lacks the band skilled instrumentalists - the songs just fail to summon up a sensation of cohesion. The album remains quite remarkable but also somewhat unfinished.
[ allmusic.com 3,5 / 5 stars ]
