release date: Nov. 18, 1974
format: 2 cd (2014 remaster)
[album rate: 4 / 5] [3,82]
producer: John Burns & Genesis
label: Virgin Records - nationality: England, UK
Track highlights,
Disc 1: 1. "The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway" (Gabriel live '78) -
2. "Fly on a Windshield" -
3. "Broadway Melody of 1974" -
5. "In the Cage" -
7. "Back in N. Y. C." -
9. "Counting Out Time" -
10. "Carpet Crawlers" (4 / 5) - -
Disc 2: 3. "Anyway" -
5. "The Lamia" -
9. "The Light Dies Down on Broadway" -
10. "Riding the Scree"
6th studio album by Genesis following one year after Selling England by the Pound is the band's last album to feature vocalist Peter Gabriel. The album is like the predecessor produced in a collaboration by John Burns and Genesis (Burns is also credited as sound engineer on Foxtrot, 1972), and it's originally released as a double vinyl album on Charisma Records consisting of 23 tracks with a total playing time above 1 hour and 34 minutes. The album is a conceptual album with Gabriel's story of a young Puerto Rican entering the capitalist centre of New York, and it's also known for the partecipation of Brian Eno on two compositions (#5 and #6). As with the bands previous two albums all songs are credited all five band members: Peter Gabriel (vocals, flute, varied instruments), Steve Hackett (guitars), Mike Rutherford (bass, 12-string guitar), Tony Banks (organ, keyboards, synths) and Phil Collins (drums, percussion, lead vocals on #9, #15, #18); although, in reality all but Gabriel worked on the music and Gabriel insisted on writing all lyrics with the result that vocals were put down (in another studio) after the music had been composed.
Musically, it's still very much 'prog rock' with experimental traits and with the most promissing songs on the first part - the vinyl A- and B-sides and Disc 1 for cd issues - and most of the more experimental stuff on the second half.
The album was released to mixed reviews but has gained status over the years as perhaps the bands absolute best. It peaked as number #10 on the British albums chart list and at number #41 on the US Billboard 200. Two songs were selected for single releases: "Counting Out Time" preceeding the album on Nov. 1st, and track #10 released as "The Carpet Crawlers" Apr. '75, making it to number #53 and #54 respectively on the British singles chart list. The latter was re-recorded in '95 and released i '99 with Collins and Gabriel sharing lead vocals as "The Carpet Crawlers 99". The album is the second consecutive album by Genesis to be enlisted in "1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die".
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway may be an overblown conceptual idea with lots of progressive rock tracks, and perhaps with a little too much music, but as a statement of the band's musical cleverness and Gabriel's narrating skills it's simply Genesis at its artistic peak. During the following tour Gabriel announced his parting with the band, which saw him pursue a great solo career, and Genesis began another music chapter with Collins as lead vocalist and better charting albums, although, the band in terms of originality and quality never again performed at this level. Although, it wasn't the first album I came accross by this band, it's nonetheless the absolute best by Genesis, imho.
Highly recommended.
[ allmusic.com 5 / 5, Rolling Stone Album Guide 4 / 5 stars ]
